Skip to main content

Navigating the delicate process of employee termination requires tact, preparation, and a keen awareness of both legal and personal considerations.  Here are five mistakes we see employers make during the termination process:

  1. Lack of Preparation: Employers should avoid entering a termination meeting without thorough preparation. If the company representative seems unprepared to provide specific reasons and documentation for the termination, it will lead to confusion and dissatisfaction from the employee. Employers need to have all relevant performance data and documentation ready to clearly justify their decisions.
  2. Impersonal Approach: If the termination is handled by company representatives who did not have any interaction with the employee, the process can feel impersonal and detached. Employers should avoid using unfamiliar faces in termination meetings. Instead, involve supervisors or managers who have a direct working relationship with the employee to add a personal touch and make the conversation more respectful and informed.
  3. Poor Timing: Employers should consider, whenever possible, when best to conduct terminations. Terminations during the holiday season can be particularly stressful. Employers should avoid scheduling terminations at times when employees might already be under increased personal stress, such as immediately after holidays or significant company events, as this can exacerbate the emotional impact of the termination.
  4. Vague Reasons for Termination: Employers should not give vague or inconsistent reasons for termination. Avoid ambiguity about whether the termination is due to individual performance or broader departmental or company issues. This lack of clarity can lead to misunderstandings and potential legal complications. Employers need to be clear and consistent about the reasons for termination.
  5. Failing to Anticipate Recording: Employers need to be mindful that the termination may be recorded by the employee, potentially without the knowledge of the HR representatives. Employers should always assume that such meetings might be recorded, especially in jurisdictions where one-party consent is sufficient. Conducting the termination as if it were being recorded can help ensure that the conversation remains professional, respectful, and legally compliant. Even though California is a two-party consent state, and it is illegal for the employee to record a termination meeting without the consent of the company representatives, and it is not likely that an illegally obtained recording could be used in subsequent legal proceedings, employers should still consider how this may look if the recording is release on social media.  Even though it may be illegally obtained, if released, the recording could impact the company’s reputation and public perception.

Avoiding these pitfalls can help employers conduct terminations more effectively, reducing the risk of legal challenges and maintaining a respectful and professional relationship with the departing employee.